September 15, 2011
Japanese planes appeared over Oahu at 1:25 p.m., Washington time, on Dec. 7, 1941. This superior addition to the snapshot genre of historical writing describes the following 24 hours, ending when FDR delivered his famous "day of infamy" message to Congress.
The History Channel resident historian Gillon (History/Univ. of Oklahoma; The Kennedy Assassination--24 Hours After: Lyndon B. Johnson's Pivotal First Day as President, 2009, etc.) reminds readers that everyone expected war. Having broken Japan's diplomatic code, American officials knew that morning that Japan's embassy had been ordered to destroy its code machines. Everyone assumed the Japanese fleet (known to have sailed) would move south to obtain desperately needed oil and natural resources from weakly defended British and Dutch Southeast Asia colonies. A San Francisco Naval station picked up news of the raid and relayed it to Washington, where a flabbergasted FDR received it at 1:47. Gillon paints a vivid picture of the scramble that followed as he summoned his cabinet, aides and Congressional leaders from their Sunday rest. Meetings throughout the day served mostly to agonize over how American forces were caught napping and exchange wild rumors (swastikas on the wings of attacking planes, Japanese troops landing on Hawaii)--as well as to vow revenge. Little useful activity and no important decisions resulted, and Gillon wisely cuts away from the confusion to deliver background information and generous biographies of FDR, Eleanor and a dozen leading figures.
An excellent introduction to Roosevelt and his times with heavy emphasis on events surrounding Pearl Harbor.
(COPYRIGHT (2011) KIRKUS REVIEWS/NIELSEN BUSINESS MEDIA, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.)
November 1, 2011
Accounts of the events leading to the Japanese attack, the attack itself, and the immediate aftermath are, of course, plentiful. This work is unusual, even unique, in that it concentrates on the actions of President Roosevelt and his closest associates as the attack unfolded and they began to come to grips with the enormous task facing the nation. Gillon, professor of history at the University of Oklahoma, does not sugarcoat Roosevelt's personal qualities. Beneath his gregarious veneer, Roosevelt was often distant, deceptive, and prepared to discard associates when they no longer were useful. But in this gigantic crisis, Gillon shows Roosevelt as decisive and an intuitive leader. Gillon effectively sets the stage by describing the administration's view of the international situation. Germany was regarded as the main threat, but as relations with Japan deteriorated, an attack was expected somewhere in the Pacific. But Pearl Harbor didn't seem a likely target. Gillon conveys the initial sense of shock and confusion as Roosevelt and his advisors get minute-by-minute updates. As the enormity of the disaster becomes clear, Roosevelt's stature seems to rapidly grow. This is an engrossing and highly informative chronicle of crisis management at a decisive moment in history.(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2011, American Library Association.)